I hot the signature dish of prime rib, it didn't stand out at least like it used to 20 years ago, my wife got a pasta dish that was dry. It took a very long time in between to get desert and the check. I would recommend a few other Italian restaurants on this same strip before going here. Try Buds Place!
Chris Bentley
-
March 28, 2025
Haven't been here in years, stopped for dinner, my wife is celiac so she ordered the gluten free pasta and she said it gave a whole new meaning to Al-dente she said it was very under cooked, I have heard that the new owners have had some quality issues, anyway our salads came with no salad dressing, and when informed of this the server took a good 20 minutes to return with the dressing so we had our salads after our pasta. My wife took her meal home with hopes of reboiling the pasta but she ended up just tossing it in the trash. All in all not a pleasant evening.
Sue Osterhout
-
April 15, 2025
Not sure what has happened but we waited A HOUR just for our salad, then our food came out, prime rib was cool not warm, other food wasn't hot, my husband got prime rib and didn't get his fries till 25 minutes AFTER his steak. We got there at 6 never was able to leave till 8:30. And not that we were sitting having a good time, we were waiting: for food, things she forgot, she cleaned off table THEN finally gave us our check, it was not as pleasant as before, waitress did tell us, at the end that it was a crazy monday. Not our fault and it was unacceptable. Donoli's used to be my favorite place but it will be a long time before we go back.
Zack T
-
February 18, 2024
Stopped here while on vacation , glad I did. Best 20oz Prime Rib I have ever had, it was absolutely delicious. If I am ever in the area I will 100% be back for a prime rib everytime.
Andrew “Spanky” Mencher
-
March 23, 2025
The service was on point. The food was plentiful, hot, and delicious. I recommend the prim rib and fish fry. The conoli wow.
Our Address
6510-6568 NY-434, Apalachin, NY 13732, USA
Claim Listing: Donoli’s
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I hot the signature dish of prime rib, it didn't stand out at least like it used to 20 years ago, my wife got a pasta dish that was dry. It took a very long time in between to get desert and the check. I would recommend a few other Italian restaurants on this same strip before going here. Try Buds Place!
Haven't been here in years, stopped for dinner, my wife is celiac so she ordered the gluten free pasta and she said it gave a whole new meaning to Al-dente she said it was very under cooked, I have heard that the new owners have had some quality issues, anyway our salads came with no salad dressing, and when informed of this the server took a good 20 minutes to return with the dressing so we had our salads after our pasta. My wife took her meal home with hopes of reboiling the pasta but she ended up just tossing it in the trash. All in all not a pleasant evening.
Not sure what has happened but we waited A HOUR just for our salad, then our food came out, prime rib was cool not warm, other food wasn't hot, my husband got prime rib and didn't get his fries till 25 minutes AFTER his steak. We got there at 6 never was able to leave till 8:30. And not that we were sitting having a good time, we were waiting: for food, things she forgot, she cleaned off table THEN finally gave us our check, it was not as pleasant as before, waitress did tell us, at the end that it was a crazy monday. Not our fault and it was unacceptable. Donoli's used to be my favorite place but it will be a long time before we go back.
Stopped here while on vacation , glad I did. Best 20oz Prime Rib I have ever had, it was absolutely delicious. If I am ever in the area I will 100% be back for a prime rib everytime.
The service was on point. The food was plentiful, hot, and delicious. I recommend the prim rib and fish fry. The conoli wow.