Quality food! Great pizza! They don't skimp on the ingredients. I ordered a steak burger too and it was superb! Love the fried onions and toppings. Im looking forward to trying lots more on the menu!
Michelle Lori
-
June 07, 2026
I’ve waited a long time to go to this highly praised venue, the service was okay, she seemed new, the food was warm, I didn’t receive an item I requested, which was removed from the bill, and I went with the Delmonico cooked medium, one side was more rare then medium, I had a baked potato with butter and sour cream, it came with 2 of those little pats of butter that are sometimes hard to open, I’m not sure where our server was but when she finally returned I requested more butter, but the potato was not very warm by then. The steak had no flavor what so ever, not that it should be seasoned, but I was wishing I had ordered the prime rib. The atmosphere seemed outdated, kind of drab. The only thing I can rave about was the chocolate chip cannoli I brought home, I should have gotten two!
Anne Marie
-
July 27, 2026
Came here last year and everything was great. However, the last couple of times I’ve been, the food hasn’t been as good. The wait staff were great this weekend, but I got vodka rigatoni and the sauce was watery and tasted like spaghettios with no flavor. Very expensive for the quality. The cannoli cake was amazing though. Not sure what happened. :/
P
-
April 22, 2026
Wouldn’t even give the restaurant a ⭐️!!! Customer BEWARE don’t go here for dinner!! My parents were celebrating their wedding anniversary on Tuesday. When asked when making reservations if it was a special occasion yes I replied celebrating 70 years of marriage, a lot good did me not even a piece of cake to honor them. But the hostess did say happy anniversary but the information wasn’t shared with their waitress til later. Sign off of Route 434 is hidden! Stick to doing bar service rather than inside seating! The fish platter was terrible instead of 5 shrimp from their on line menu got only 3 shrimp! NEED TO UPDATE YOUR MENU!!The fish dinner was NASTY!! The prime rib wasn’t all that great, probably cooked last Friday and reheated on Tuesday. They even went as far as to mess up salads how for gods sake’s do you mess up a salad!! For a $99 meal including tip it’s was a hot mess. $99 for 2 people regardless if it includes tip is a bit absurd. Never sending anyone to this establishment NASTY!
tracy legg
-
November 26, 2025
Well, the waitress was nice. She did not do a very good job of satisfying a dissatisfied customer. My friend and I went there both got the French dip sandwich. I am 100% sure that it was microwaved. Parts of the meat were so black and dried out other parts were gray other parts were pink a sure sign of being microwaved. The onions were totally raw underneath the cheese and my order of french fries were stone cold. When I told the waitress about it, she did offer to replace our food, but at that point, I did not want anything else . very very disappointed. It’s been my experience working in the industry field for well over 20 years that if you have a customer complaint the manager should address the issue. This did not happen. We still tipped the waitress because it wasn’t her fault as far as the food quality, but her lack of resolving the issue in a professional manner was lacking. . $40 for nothing… I will never go back there again
Our Address
6510-6568 NY-434, Apalachin, NY 13732, USA
Claim Listing: Donoli’s
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Quality food! Great pizza! They don't skimp on the ingredients. I ordered a steak burger too and it was superb! Love the fried onions and toppings. Im looking forward to trying lots more on the menu!
I’ve waited a long time to go to this highly praised venue, the service was okay, she seemed new, the food was warm, I didn’t receive an item I requested, which was removed from the bill, and I went with the Delmonico cooked medium, one side was more rare then medium, I had a baked potato with butter and sour cream, it came with 2 of those little pats of butter that are sometimes hard to open, I’m not sure where our server was but when she finally returned I requested more butter, but the potato was not very warm by then. The steak had no flavor what so ever, not that it should be seasoned, but I was wishing I had ordered the prime rib. The atmosphere seemed outdated, kind of drab. The only thing I can rave about was the chocolate chip cannoli I brought home, I should have gotten two!
Came here last year and everything was great. However, the last couple of times I’ve been, the food hasn’t been as good. The wait staff were great this weekend, but I got vodka rigatoni and the sauce was watery and tasted like spaghettios with no flavor. Very expensive for the quality. The cannoli cake was amazing though. Not sure what happened. :/
Wouldn’t even give the restaurant a ⭐️!!! Customer BEWARE don’t go here for dinner!! My parents were celebrating their wedding anniversary on Tuesday. When asked when making reservations if it was a special occasion yes I replied celebrating 70 years of marriage, a lot good did me not even a piece of cake to honor them. But the hostess did say happy anniversary but the information wasn’t shared with their waitress til later. Sign off of Route 434 is hidden! Stick to doing bar service rather than inside seating! The fish platter was terrible instead of 5 shrimp from their on line menu got only 3 shrimp! NEED TO UPDATE YOUR MENU!!The fish dinner was NASTY!! The prime rib wasn’t all that great, probably cooked last Friday and reheated on Tuesday. They even went as far as to mess up salads how for gods sake’s do you mess up a salad!! For a $99 meal including tip it’s was a hot mess. $99 for 2 people regardless if it includes tip is a bit absurd. Never sending anyone to this establishment NASTY!
Well, the waitress was nice. She did not do a very good job of satisfying a dissatisfied customer. My friend and I went there both got the French dip sandwich. I am 100% sure that it was microwaved. Parts of the meat were so black and dried out other parts were gray other parts were pink a sure sign of being microwaved. The onions were totally raw underneath the cheese and my order of french fries were stone cold. When I told the waitress about it, she did offer to replace our food, but at that point, I did not want anything else . very very disappointed. It’s been my experience working in the industry field for well over 20 years that if you have a customer complaint the manager should address the issue. This did not happen. We still tipped the waitress because it wasn’t her fault as far as the food quality, but her lack of resolving the issue in a professional manner was lacking. . $40 for nothing… I will never go back there again