Casey is the best waitress!!!! We’ve had her on multiple occasions and she’s been fabulous every time!!! Waitress of the year for sure!!!! Extremely pleasant and helpful!! Food is undoubtedly one of the best if not the best in New York State! Love this place. Worth the hour and half drive. Negative 24 degrees didn’t stop us from making the trip. #waitressCasey#1
Joel Guevarra (U of T Varsity Blues)
-
August 10, 2026
Simply amazing! Family owned and operated. The family is kind, welcoming and makes you feel at home The food is outstanding authentic Italian. If you are gluten free (like my girlfriend), they have options and it’s delicious. Highly recommend.
I had the Charlie special pizza and my girlfriend had the same with a gluten free crust.
Christine Wood
-
April 22, 2026
Gina was our waitress. She was very attentive, informative and fun! We had a party of 8 and she took great care of us!
The food was amazing! All 8 of us had something different and everyone said they would definitely order the same again!
Great night! Thank you Charlie and crew!
Daniel Martin
-
May 18, 2026
Coming to Aiello's is like coming home again. Service is warm, friendly and efficient. Margreat provides great service with a personal touch. The selection and quality of food is amazing from a slice of pizza to Southern Italian specialties. It is a family restaurant where we are greeted like family. Josphina tends bar and serves too! Aiello's offers a full selection of home-made canoli's, however we were too full to have dessert. Definitely worth the ride.
Charles Hollenbeck
-
March 14, 2026
Absolutely no complaints. My parents’ pizza was solid, and burnt well in such a way that it was a marbling of fluffy, soft dough with blackened crackles.
My chicken Alfredo was excellent. The sauce was like liquid parmesan, and not thin and tasteless and sad. And the simple fact is that Aiello’s makes REAL food. The breading was good, the chicken was juicy, not dry and flat.
It was such a refreshing meal to see real food, made the right way, with no corners cut. And? The atmosphere is a classic, and the service was good.
Our Address
26-77 Main St, Whitney Point, NY 13862, USA
Claim Listing: Aiello’s Ristorante
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Casey is the best waitress!!!! We’ve had her on multiple occasions and she’s been fabulous every time!!! Waitress of the year for sure!!!! Extremely pleasant and helpful!! Food is undoubtedly one of the best if not the best in New York State! Love this place. Worth the hour and half drive. Negative 24 degrees didn’t stop us from making the trip. #waitressCasey#1
Simply amazing! Family owned and operated. The family is kind, welcoming and makes you feel at home The food is outstanding authentic Italian. If you are gluten free (like my girlfriend), they have options and it’s delicious. Highly recommend. I had the Charlie special pizza and my girlfriend had the same with a gluten free crust.
Gina was our waitress. She was very attentive, informative and fun! We had a party of 8 and she took great care of us! The food was amazing! All 8 of us had something different and everyone said they would definitely order the same again! Great night! Thank you Charlie and crew!
Coming to Aiello's is like coming home again. Service is warm, friendly and efficient. Margreat provides great service with a personal touch. The selection and quality of food is amazing from a slice of pizza to Southern Italian specialties. It is a family restaurant where we are greeted like family. Josphina tends bar and serves too! Aiello's offers a full selection of home-made canoli's, however we were too full to have dessert. Definitely worth the ride.
Absolutely no complaints. My parents’ pizza was solid, and burnt well in such a way that it was a marbling of fluffy, soft dough with blackened crackles. My chicken Alfredo was excellent. The sauce was like liquid parmesan, and not thin and tasteless and sad. And the simple fact is that Aiello’s makes REAL food. The breading was good, the chicken was juicy, not dry and flat. It was such a refreshing meal to see real food, made the right way, with no corners cut. And? The atmosphere is a classic, and the service was good.